gpu: optimize atlas packer for smallest sizes

Previously, the packer optimized for the smalles space where the image
fits. Empirically, smaller atlases can be achieved by greedily picking the
smallest total area.

Signed-off-by: Elias Naur <mail@eliasnaur.com>

gpu/pack.go

@@ -46,40 +46,54 @@ func (p *packer) newPage() {
 }
 
 func (p *packer) tryAdd(s image.Point) (placement, bool) {
-	// Go backwards to prioritize smaller spaces first.
+	var (
-	for i := len(p.spaces) - 1; i >= 0; i-- {
+		bestIdx   = -1
-		space := p.spaces[i]
+		bestSpace image.Rectangle
+		bestSize  = image.Pt(p.maxDim, p.maxDim)
+	)
+	// Go backwards to prioritize smaller spaces.
+	for i, space := range p.spaces {
 		rightSpace := space.Dx() - s.X
 		bottomSpace := space.Dy() - s.Y
-		if rightSpace >= 0 && bottomSpace >= 0 {
+		if rightSpace < 0 || bottomSpace < 0 {
+			continue
+		}
+		idx := len(p.sizes) - 1
+		size := p.sizes[idx]
+		if x := space.Min.X + s.X; x > size.X {
+			size.X = x
+		}
+		if y := space.Min.Y + s.Y; y > size.Y {
+			size.Y = y
+		}
+		if size.X*size.Y < bestSize.X*bestSize.Y {
+			bestIdx = i
+			bestSpace = space
+			bestSize = size
+		}
+	}
+	if bestIdx == -1 {
+		return placement{}, false
+	}
 	// Remove space.
-			p.spaces[i] = p.spaces[len(p.spaces)-1]
+	p.spaces[bestIdx] = p.spaces[len(p.spaces)-1]
 	p.spaces = p.spaces[:len(p.spaces)-1]
 	// Put s in the top left corner and add the (at most)
 	// two smaller spaces.
-			pos := space.Min
+	pos := bestSpace.Min
-			if bottomSpace > 0 {
+	if rem := bestSpace.Dy() - s.Y; rem > 0 {
 		p.spaces = append(p.spaces, image.Rectangle{
 			Min: image.Point{X: pos.X, Y: pos.Y + s.Y},
-					Max: image.Point{X: space.Max.X, Y: space.Max.Y},
+			Max: image.Point{X: bestSpace.Max.X, Y: bestSpace.Max.Y},
 		})
 	}
-			if rightSpace > 0 {
+	if rem := bestSpace.Dx() - s.X; rem > 0 {
 		p.spaces = append(p.spaces, image.Rectangle{
 			Min: image.Point{X: pos.X + s.X, Y: pos.Y},
-					Max: image.Point{X: space.Max.X, Y: pos.Y + s.Y},
+			Max: image.Point{X: bestSpace.Max.X, Y: pos.Y + s.Y},
 		})
 	}
 	idx := len(p.sizes) - 1
-			size := &p.sizes[idx]
+	p.sizes[idx] = bestSize
-			if x := pos.X + s.X; x > size.X {
-				size.X = x
-			}
-			if y := pos.Y + s.Y; y > size.Y {
-				size.Y = y
-			}
 	return placement{Idx: idx, Pos: pos}, true
 }
-	}
-	return placement{}, false
-}